Periodic Tenancy 1954 Act: What happens when a business lease continues?

It could be easy just to let a business lease continue once the lease comes to an end. The tenant will continue to trade from the premises, and you, as the landlord, will keep accepting the monthly rent. It’s easy, and everything carries on as it was. This is known as a ‘periodic tenancy’ or ‘holding over’. However, there is a set of complications that may come with this agreement. Here, we’ll look at periodic tenancies within the 1954 Act. 

Allowing a business lease to continue without formalising its status will bring various legal implications regarding property possession, rent control, and security of tenure. Here, we’ll unpack exactly what happens when a commercial lease rolls over, the difference between an informal periodic tenancy and a statutory continuation, and how commercial landlords can regain control of their property or update their rental income. 

Holding Over vs. An Implied Periodic Tenancy

When a commercial lease has surpassed its expiration date, its legal status will very much depend on whether or not the original lease was protected by the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, or if it was ever ‘contracted out’.  This is the crucial thing that determines how the law views the commercial lease continuation. Let’s look at the two different scenarios where this may or may not apply. 

Scenario A: The Original Lease Was Protected 

If the original lease was protected by the 1954 Act, it does not end when the expiry date passes. Instead, Section 24 of the Act is used to extend the tenancy automatically. This is not legally a true periodic tenancy according to the 1954 Act, but is instead a statutory continuation of the lease. This means that the tenant will retain full security of tenure, and they will have the legal right to occupy the premises under the same terms as before. This will continue until the tenancy is formally terminated using the correct mechanisms outlined in the Act. (Gov.UK)

Scenario B: The Original Lease Was Contracted Out 

If, for some reason, the original commercial lease was contracted out according to the 1954 Act, the tenant has no statutory right to continue occupying the building once the expiry date has passed. If your commercial tenant stays and you continue accepting rent without having a new lease in place, you’ll be entering a dangerous legal minefield. 

If you continue to accept money from your tenant past the expiry date of the lease agreement, the courts may rule that you have created an implied periodic tenancy. The tenant may also then automatically acquire protection because of this. This will strip away your rights to be able to claim back your property. (Gov.UK)

What Happens to Rent and Lease Terms During Periodic Tenancies According to the 1954 Act?

So, what are your rights as a commercial landlord when it comes to property maintenance, insurance, and rental income with a protected lease? 

The Terms of the Lease Persist

As mentioned before, the periodic tenancy will have the same protection as the original contract. This means that all responsibilities and clauses will remain legally binding on both parties. The tenant will need to continue maintaining the property according to the original lease. A few other things that won’t change are the insurance provisions, service charge contributions, and permitted-use clauses. (Gov.UK)

The Problem of ‘Frozen’ Rent

The rent amount is another thing that remains the same, and so the tenant is only legally obligated to pay the rent that was due at the end of the fixed term. So, if the commercial property rental market has boomed over the past few years, you may potentially lose out on money every month because of the outdated market rate. (Gov.UK)

Interim Rent

To save yourself from being financially penalised while the lease continues as a commercial landlord, you can apply for interim rent according to the 1954 Act. (Gov.UK)

Your tenant can also apply for interim rent through the court, or you can set an interim rent while the lease is held over between you and your tenant. This will be set at the current market value and can also be backdated to the earliest date the lease was terminated formally under statutory notice.  This will allow you to recoup market-rate losses that have been incurred during negotiations.

How to End a Statutory Continuation

You won’t be able to end a statutory continuation under a periodic tenancy within the 1954 Act by sending an eviction letter or changing your locks. There are specific statutory forms that need to be deployed using chronological precision if you are looking to protect your asset or update your lease. Providing a notice to vacate is one of the ways to do this. 

Section 25 Notice

You’ll need to serve a section 25 notice if you want to bring the holding-over period to an end, and this needs to be given between 6 and 12 months prior to the termination date of the lease. You’ll need to state one of the following intentions below in this notice for a periodic tenancy within the 1954 Act: 

• You are willing to grant a new lease: You’ll need to outline your proposed new terms with the updated market rent and proposed lease length. 
• You oppose a new lease: You’ll also need to state which of the following strict statutory grounds under Section 30 you’re relying on to reclaim possession of the vacant building. This includes your intention to demolish or redevelop the building or your desire to use the building for your own business. (Gov.UK)

Section 26 Request

If your tenant wants to, they can serve a Section 26 Request on you as the landlord. This is a form that officially requests a new lease with new terms and sets a new timeframe. If you receive one of these, you have two months to formally object if you wish to oppose the renewal on Section 30 grounds. If you miss this window, however, you will lose your right to oppose the renewal. (Gov.UK)

Section 27 Notice

If a tenant decides they want to leave the lease during a statutory continuation, they’ll need to serve a Section 27 Notice, giving you at least 3 months’ written notice to end the statutory tenancy. This will ensure that you have a financial buffer and enough time to find a new tenant. 

(Gov.UK)

Key Takeaways for Commercial Landlords

When you allow a business lease to continue past its term without managing it properly, you’re entering dangerous territory. Here’s what you can do to prevent this: 

• Audit your dates early: Make sure you start renewing your commercial leases at least 12 to 18 months before they end.  
• Beware the acceptance of rent: if the lease was contracted out, don’t accept rent once the lease has expired without an explicit ‘tenancy at will’ agreement or an ongoing, documented negotiation for a new lease. This way, you prevent the accidental creation of an unprotected periodic tenancy turning into a protected one. 
• Use interim rent to protect cash flow: if your tenant is holding over at a low rental rate, make sure you initiate a Section 25 process as soon as possible so that you trigger your right to claim current market-value interim rent. 

There are strict timelines governing the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, where a single day’s error can invalidate a notice. So, it is important to use the 1954 Act with periodic tenancies as a foundation for your commercial portfolio’s strategy. Make sure you consult a specialist property solicitor before serving notices or modifying your rent collection. 

If you’re looking for landlord insurance to help protect your rental property, make sure you get in touch with our team of specialists for a quote today on 01788 818 670. Or you can visit our advice centre for more information on how to manage your rental property.